The Myth of Redemptive Violence

No Evil for Evil

Around the country, people are polarized about whether gun control or widespread ownership of guns would make us safer.  My earlier posts on this topic also touched on the U.S. culture of violence and the growing economic inequity, which is violent in itself and is linked to increasing violence.  Today’s post addresses the violent “myth” that underlies our culture:

In his work on the Powers [the institutions that rule our world], Walter Wink claims that the primary myth of our time is the “Myth of Redemptive Violence.”  This myth, which is so pervasive in contemporary U.S. culture, has its roots in the ancient Enuma Elish, a Babylonian creation story about the struggle between cosmic order and chaos.  The idea is that force must be used to bring order out of chaos and that the only way to conquer evil is through domination and violence. This story has been played out around the world for generations, and continues to be played out today.

The pervasiveness of violence among human beings brings to mind the ancient biblical story of Cain’s murder of Abel and the subsequent multiplication of violence articulated by Cain’s descendent, Lamech: “If Cain is avenged sevenfold, truly Lamech seventy-seven fold.” (Gen. 4:24) It is this very cycle of violence that Jesus seeks to remedy when he tells his followers that they must forgive even seventy-seven (or seventy times seven) times (Matt. 18:22). Sadly, Jesus’ rejection of violence and his embrace of nonviolence, so central to his life and message, have been ignored by many who claim to be Christian. And although it was the political, military, and economic Powers, supported by the religious establishment, that put Jesus to death, much of official Christianity throughout history has supported similar institutions and systems that are based on domination and violence. Walter Wink calls this changing but similarly interlocking network of worldly Powers “the Domination System.” Others call it “empire.”

Empires, too, function out of the myth of redemptive violence, under the illusion that domination and violence can bring order out of chaos and can conquer evil. Furthermore, empires seek to be ultimate and absolute, demanding people’s loyalty and service. Those who resist are seen as enemies and subversives, as Jesus was.

As someone who seeks to follow (not just worship) Jesus, I choose the nonviolent path that he chose.  And I seek and work for a world transformed by by Love, as he did.

The photograph I chose for this blog is from an article that appeared in, of all places, The Economist.  The article is entitled:  “Evil beyond imagining:  If even the slaughter of 20 small children cannot end America’s infatuation with guns, nothing will.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s